The recent sentencing of Indian national Atharva Shailesh Sathawane to 18 years in a US prison for defrauding elderly victims of $15 million has sparked renewed debate about the risks associated with trusted mobility and access frameworks. Sathawane’s conviction is not an isolated case; rather, it reflects a troubling pattern of Indian nationals being implicated in serious crimes abroad. These crimes, ranging from large-scale financial fraud to alleged violent conspiracies, have harmful consequences for host societies and challenge the perception of India as a reliable partner.
Escalation from Crime to Security-Relevant Territory
The case of Sathawane comes alongside other high-profile prosecutions involving Indian nationals. One notable example is the US indictment of Nikhil Gupta, allegedly linked to India’s intelligence agency RAW, in a murder-for-hire conspiracy. This represents a significant escalation from conventional criminal activity to matters directly relevant to national security. Such incidents undermine India’s carefully cultivated image as a stabilizing partner in Western capitals. They also reinforce security concerns within Western political and intelligence circles, particularly in the wake of the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada, which has already strained relations.
India’s Reliability as a Strategic Partner Faces Growing Western Scrutiny
Western states maintain deep migration, technology, and economic corridors with India, viewing it as a strategic partner. However, these recent developments substantiate fears that India may not be as reliable as projected. The combination of financial fraud cases like Sathawane’s and security-linked prosecutions such as Gupta’s highlights that partner-state status does not eliminate risks. Instead, these cases demonstrate that India-related concerns are becoming more prominent in Western discourse, raising questions about trust, oversight, and the future of bilateral cooperation.
Read More: U.S. Crackdown Uncovers Indian Nationals’ Human Trafficking and Crime Rings
